Some longtime Portlanders remember a saltier city, arching an eyebrow at the influx of chefy restaurants luring national media and gastro-tourists. But plenty of Portland’s time-tested, unfussy places have managed to stick around — reason to think that old- and new-school can coexist just fine.
Before Maine had some 150 craft breweries, it had one: Geary Brewing Company opened in 1986 and has been bottling its crisp Brit-style pale ale ever since. But even the granddaddy of Maine breweries changes with the times, lately introducing a “contemporary” line that includes Pulling Traps, a juicy, hazy, big-flavored (and trendy) New England–style IPA.
The hurried weekday lunch crowd jostles through 72-year-old Micucci Grocery to snag slabs of plain or pepperoni Sicilian (above), downing the huge square slices at standing-room-only sidewalk counters. At Radici, open since last spring, a James Beard Award–nominated chef hand-mixes naturally leavened sourdough and tops it with the likes of Taleggio cheese and caper honey.
Everything at Gilbert’s Chowder House is classic, from crispy fried whole-belly clams to grilled red-snapper hot dogs to lobster stew, the latter a creamy, grease-slicked broth and big chunks of lobster ladled into a paper bowl. A few blocks away, at Eventide Oyster Co., the lobster stew (above) is just as rich — but accented with green curry and maitake mushrooms.
Doughnuts just look like doughnuts at Tony’s Donut Shop, where they’re glazed, tossed in cinnamon and sugar, or served plain — perfect for dunking in a cup of kept-warm coffee. The s’more cruller topped with brûléed marshmallow at HiFi Donuts (above) looks like a dessert a pastry chef would make at a fine French joint, aptly paired with a macchiato from HiFi’s espresso bar.
Neapolitan immigrant Giovanni Amato started selling Maine-style Italians from his Portland pushcart in 1902, and the Amato’s franchise still serves the fundamentally humble sandwich — no fancy Euro-style meats, just deli ham with cheese, onions, green bell pepper, tomato, black olives, and olive oil in a sub roll. Monte’s Fine Foods, opened in 2019, grills the thinly sliced ham and folds everything in a freshly baked flatbread (above) for a dressed-up but earnest homage to the original.
Whether it’s cod, haddock, or halibut, New Englanders have straightforwardly broiled their fish with buttery bread crumbs and served it with a lemon wedge since time immemorial, and that’s still how haddock is done at Becky’s Diner (above). A few wharfs away, also on Commercial Street, Scales is an upmarket place where haddock gets decked out with chanterelles, hakurei turnips, cipollini onions, and fumet cream.
The post Portland Eats Showdown: Old School Versus New appeared first on Down East.
